Views of Vietnam

Source: https://c1.staticflickr.com/9/8376/8525983904_2377fabcd0_b.jpg

By Felicia Teba

Target Students: 8th grade US History

Skills: Sourcing and Contextualization

Topic: The Vietnam War

Essential Question: How did the various  aspects of the war in Vietnam impact opinions on the war?

Description: The questions in this set of documents help students to understand that war doesn’t just impact a nation, but that it impacts individuals, and the Vietnam War was one of the most contentious.


Source 1: A Letter Home

August 27, 1967

Dear all,

Surprise! Charlton Heston visited our company for a few minutes, and I shook hands with him! He looked like an old farmer the way he was dressed in old drab green jungle fatigues. He said “almost everybody is backing us over here” and “I’d like a beer.”

Can’t think of anything else to say. The new library opened up– air conditioned and quiet.

Well, cheerio

Rick

Source: Dear America: Letters Home from Vietnam, edited by Bernard Edelman, p.158.

Questions

  1. Why do you think Rick wrote this letter?
  2. Who is Charlton Heston, and why was he visiting Rick’s company?
  3. Who do you think Rick was writing to in this letter?
  4. What do you think the war was like at this point in 1967?
  5. Did Rick write his letter before or after the Tet offensive? Would that have impacted what he wrote about?

Source 2 & 3: Different Views of Support

Protestors_carrying_an_American_flag_at_a_rally_on_the_University_of_Washington_campus_May_7_1970
Protestors carrying an American flag at a rally on the University of Washington campus May 7 1970

 

Richard M. Nixon shaking hands with armed forces in Vietnam 1969
Richard M. Nixon shaking hands with armed forces in Vietnam 1969

Protestors carrying an American flag at a rally on the University of Washington campus, May 7, 1970  Source
Richard M. Nixon shaking hands with armed forces in Vietnam 1969 Source

Questions

  1. Who is in this picture?
  2. What is going on?
  3. Digging Deeper Questions
  4. Why would it be important to take a picture like this?
  5. What audience would like this picture? Which audience would dislike this picture?
  6. On the picture on the right, why is the American flag upside down?

Source 4: “A Day in Vietnam”

Questions

  1. Who do you think made this video?
  2. Who is the audience?
  3. Why was this video made?
  4. What reason could there be for a video like this?
  5. If you were an American civilian at this time, how might this video impact your opinion of the war?

Reflections: In this assignment, I think I could have done better at providing a context for when I would teach these particular unit. To use this lesson, I would add a lecture that gives background to each of the sources, so that students are not left confuse about what I am asking them to look for. With this lesson, I think it would also be good to stick with just one type of source, like just soldiers letters, so that my set of sources is not too broad.

 

One Minute to Midnight: Decision-Making During the Cuban Missile Crisis


Target Students:
11th and 12th grade

Historical thinking skills: This lesson develops students’ sourcing and contextualization skills.

Essential question: On what bases did the US and USSR make decisions leading up to and during the Cuban Missile Crisis?

Context within Curriculum: To participate in this lesson students must be familiar with the broad contours of post-WWII global politics. In particular, students should be able to describe key differences between the US and USSR, be aware of the existence of NATO and the Warsaw Pact, and have basic knowledge of nuclear weapons.

Primary documents:

  1. CIA Special National Intelligence Estimate, “Major Consequences of Certain U.S. Courses of Action on Cuba,” October 20, 1962.
  2. Prime Minister Fidel Castro’s letter to Premier Khrushchev, October 26, 1962.
  3. USSR, Cable, TOP SECRET, Dobrynin Report of Meeting with Robert Kennedy on Worsening Threat, October 27, 1962.

All sources via The Harvard Kennedy School of Government’s Belfer Center at

Key Documents

Scaffolding questions:

  • Who (or what) wrote/produced these documents?
    • How does the identity of the author change the way we interpret the documents?
    • What were the author’s goals or purposes?
  • These documents are very different from one another. How does their form affect the way we interact with them as historians?
  • Who would have read these documents and what kind of information would they have wanted from them? How might that information have been used?
  • What can we infer about the relationship between Cuba and the USSR from Castro’s letter? Further, what do we know about US-Cuba relations at this time?

Goals: Students will synthesize what they know about Cold War history (context), international relations, and that which they can infer using these documents to develop an explanation of the Cuban Missile Crisis:

  • The US, USSR, and Cuba all sought security
    • The documents support this (compromise re: NATO missiles in Turkey; Cuba’s fear of invasion by the US; US worries that its actions could provoke retaliation by the USSR)
  • Governments make decisions, predictions, with limited information
    • Implication: Decisions cannot be perfectly rational; based on predictions about others’ behavior

Students produce:

Students will be divided into four smaller groups, two groups assuming the role of the US and two becoming the Soviet Union. The individuals within each of these small groups will work collaboratively to analyzing all three documents included in the lesson. These groups are then asked to develop a cohesive “policy proposal” to the entire class. These proposals can take a wide range of forms, although it is essential that students identify 1) a “policy priority” that is rooted in a group’s reading of the primary material (e.g. removal of US missiles in Turkey) and 2) a rationale that details the group’s reasoning for making the specific recommendation that they have chosen (e.g. “we recommend invading Cuba because the CIA report indicates…”).

Reflection:

With this activity I set out to use an exciting, high-profile incident to guide students to a broader understanding of the machinations of international politics. The process of developing the lesson and, the helpful feedback I have received from peers in particular, has helped me to identify major shortcomings that have both improved this lesson and will help me produce stronger lessons in the future. To fully realize the potential of learning through primary documents, I have found that it is essential that lessons be appropriately sequenced and scaffolded. Striking the balance between frustrating students by presenting them with materials they are ill-equipped to understand and over-scaffolding to the point of boredom will be a focus of mine as I grow as a teacher.

Title Image: EXCOMM meeting at the White House Cabinet Room during the Cuban Missile Crisis on October 29, 1962

 

Literacy DBL Design Project

An A B C, for baby patriotsWorking as individuals or in 2 person teams, students will design a document-based lesson (DBL) question suitable for inclusion in our iBook (available at iTunes).

See Class  6 for recommendations for DBLs and Teaching with Documents. Your DBL will include:

  1. Introduction of the DBL with brief historic context as needed.
  2. Generative / essential question
  3. About 5 – 8 related documents (image, text, video, audio) that will assist the students in answering the generative question
  4. Clear statement of what students will be asked to do
  5. Close reading scaffolding question for each document to assist the student in examining the document

A good example of a DBL is Progress and Poverty in Industrial America  This is a pdf version of one of my iBooks. (note: you will not have full function of all the gallery and video widgets). It uses 11 documents, which is a bit more than I expect for your DBL.

The DBL Design Assignment will be accomplished in steps:

Step 1: Develop a proposal which will be submitted for peer review. You should be prepared to deliver a 2 min pitch to class. (not a written assignment to be turned in)
Due date:  10/12.

We’ll do a bit of “speed dating” of our ideas for the DBL Assignment. Students will form two lines and have 2 minutes to pitch their DBL design idea to each other and share some feedback. Then one line will shift and we repeated the pitch exchange. In all students will pitch their idea three times.

The goal of this phase is to gather feedback from peers regarding the following:

  1. You have an interesting generative / essential question worth answering.
  2. Your initial appraisal indicates there are suitable documents available.
  3. You have an idea for how students will be asked interpret your documents.

Step 2: Submit a preliminary idea for your DBL design project for Peter’s feedback by 10/19. It should be posted to a shared Google folder.

Here’s a short video on using shared Google folder

It can be in the form of a Google doc that addresses:

  1. Where will you use it?  Grade, course, etc
  2. An interesting generative / essential question worth answering.
  3. 3 -5 suitable documents (include links).
  4. A brief explanation of “what are the kids going to do?”

Note: This is not intended to be a fully developed lesson. Just an idea of where you intend to go.

Step 3: Prepare content for iBooks Author lab session on 11/23

Workflow? See this guide Getting Ready for iBooks Author 57KB pdf

Step 4: iBooks Author design session 11/23

Step 5: Peer review of draft iBook 11/30

Step 6: Write a reflection on your DBL design process and post to our blog (your final post). It will also be added to your iBook chapter – due 12/6.

Step 7: Final design session in Digital lab 12/7


Title: “An A B C, for baby patriots”
Creator: Ames, Mary Frances
Publisher: Dean & Son
Place of Publication: London (160a Fleet Street E.C.)
Publication Date: [1899]
Archive: University of Florida UF00086056:00001

“I Can Be Your Hero, Baby [America]:” Thomas Hutchinson and Colonial Perception

Thomas Hutchinson

Grade Level: Grade 11 American History

Lesson Context: This lesson is intended to conclude discussion of the loyalists as a part of the American Revolution. The lesson asks them to analyze different images from the colonial period to get a better understanding of loyalism and its impacts in the American colonies.

Essential Question:Was Thomas Hutchinson the villain that many American patriots made him out to be or was he an American hero?

Historical Thinking Skill: Contextualization and Sourcing

Primary Sources: Cited in Bailyn, Thomas Hutchinson in Context, The Ordeal Revisited

The Virtuous Patriot
Image 2 – Nathanael Low’s The Virtuous Patriot,
1775, cited in Bailyn article above
Revere Wicked Statesman
Image 1 – Paul Revere’s Wicked Statesman,
1774

Click to enlarge images

Scaffolding Questions (used for both images):

  1. What kinds of imagery does the artist use to depict Thomas Hutchinson?
  2. What kinds of things would you assume from this print about what people thought of Hutchinson?
  3. Do you think this image is representative of the feelings of all American colonists about Hutchinson?

Rationale: Students will be encouraged to consider the types of images and metaphors that each artist uses to describe Thomas Hutchinson in each image. Students should compare/contrast them.

Scaffolding questions for discussion:

What has changed from image 1 to image 2?

What was going on in the colonies and Great Britain between 1774 and 1775, when these two sources were published?

What other questions would you ask about these sources to better understand Thomas Hutchinson as a historical figure?

Suggested assignment for further analysis:

Based on discussion and students’ answers to the scaffolding questions for each individual image, students should chose the image they find more compelling, and create their own image that reflects similar themes.  For instance, if they decide that loyalists such as Thomas Hutchinson were patriots who wanted freedom but also wanted to maintain relationship with Great Britain, they would choose the second image, and use similar metaphors in their own drawing.

Reflection:

With this particular lesson, it is important to bring the two historical thinking skills (contextualization and sourcing) to the forefront of discussion. Students should begin to recognize that the sources, produced in 1774 and 1775 respectively, by different artists, both in Boston, reflected changing perceptions of loyalists during the war. By 1775, the drama of the American Revolution had escalated, and Thomas Hutchinson was no longer the governor of Massachusetts. The second image, rather than representing his death, represents instead his fall from power, and the mourning of those loyalists who supported him.


Image Credit:

Wikimedia Commons

Massachusetts Colonial Governor, Thomas Hutchinson

1741 by Edward Truman