Manifest Destiny & the Self-Justification for an American Empire

Image Courtesy of Library of Congress

Context: American Progress by John Gast was painted in 1872 and depicts an angelic woman, Columbia – the personification of the United States, moving west across the continent.

Icebreaker Prompt: Analyze this painting. What symbols can be found in this work. What was John Gast, trying to express with this painting? What might it reflect of American Society’s views on expansion for the time?

Response: Columbia is depicted leading a host of white settlers and explorers, while Native Americans and bison flee before her. She holds in her hands a telegraph wire and we see railroads, stage coaches, and wagons trailing in her wake. Perhaps most notably Columbia is seen a being of light which she brings with her from the east while before her is darkness.

From this painting we are lead to believe that American Expansion is an almost holy experience. The angel of American Civilization tames the land and drives away the “savage”. For Americans at the time Manifest Destiny, the expansion west and the development of the land for economic exploitation, was a birthright.

Image Courtesy of Library of Congress

Context: “A Trifle Embarrassed” by Keppler, Udo J. for Puck Magazine from 1898. Print shows Uncle Sam and Columbia standing at the entrance to the “U.S. Foundling Asylum” as a basket of crying children labeled “Puerto Rico, Cuba, Hawaii, [and] Philippine” is presented to them by arms labeled “Manifest Destiny”. Within the walls of the asylum are four children labeled “Texas, New Mexico, Cal. [and] Alaska” playing together.

The caption at the bottom reads: “Uncle Sam: Gosh! I wish they wouldn’t come quite so many in a bunch; but, if I’ve got to take them, I guess I can do as well by them as I’ve done by the others!”

Icebreaker Prompt: Look at this cartoon and come up with a series of questions you have about what you see.

Response:

  1. How did Manifest Destiny lead to colonies outside of the Western Hemisphere?
  2. How did Americans view themselves when it came to occupying lands in the continental West and for colonies that were in the Caribbean and Pacific?
  3. How is a race a factor in this cartoon and what does it say about American attitudes at the time about non-white peoples?
  4. What does Uncle Sam’s quote about getting “so many in a bunch” tell us? What lead to the US getting dominion over so many far flung lands at once?
Image Courtesy of PICRYL

Context: Union Army General during the Civil War and then 18th President of the United States, Ulysses S. Grant, is seen here as a juggler while standing on a cigar box titled Habana. He is juggling rings with the names of potential U. S. possessions and spheres of influence written on them. Rings include Canada, Mexico, Honduras, Chile, Peru, and Brazil. The large ring on the right has United States of America written on it and includes the rings Alaska, Texas, Washington Territory, Arizona, New Mexico and California.

Icebreaker Prompt: With a partner draw a map or a cartoon that depicts the US sphere of influence. Then discuss how you think all these territories relate to America’s Manifest Destiny.

Response:

  1. While the US didn’t directly control places like Canada, Mexico, Central and South America its military and economic prowess dominated these areas.
  2. The US was composed of continental acquisitions like Texas, California, and Oregon that would be made into states, but areas outside, especially islands like Samoa and Cuba were treated as colonies for economic exploitation.
  3. American Politicians were expected and judged by their ability to bring more areas under US economic and political domination.

3 Replies to “Manifest Destiny & the Self-Justification for an American Empire”

  1. Bruce! Love, love, love the topic. American Expansion/Manifest Destiny is so essential to our American history. Really great job with these details, especially with the American Progress painting. The holiness of the westward movement of white settlers is certainly a huge part of the formation of our nation and foundation of religious belief. Also very cool how the second image has so much similarity to the one Professor Pappas showed us. I think there’s some great room for discussion in the third image about the way Grant is dressed as well. Some point/counter-point to be had about whether he makes juggling look cool?

  2. This post does a great job at connecting westward expansion with international policy regarding subjugated territories. I particularly like the second image; this is my first time seeing this one but it’s very striking for a number of different reasons. The quote at the bottom sums it up nicely too. The third image is also a great example of how politicians in the late 19th century were able to combine the hype of Manifest Destiny with the influence of the Monroe Doctrine. Great job!

  3. I agree with Kyle and Olivia’s observations. And yes, image 2 looks a lot like the one I shared – both from same magazine – Puck. You offer lots of supports for students to explore the images with a close read. And build understanding regarding Manifest Destiny and American Imperialism.

    One suggestion – would be to reverse order of images 2 and 3 so that they are chronological. That opens up the opportunity to see how attitudes (as reflected in cartoons) changed over time – a point made in your post title.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.